Corporate Law
Preparing Your Business for Sale
The ten things that go wrong on deal after deal, the eight decisions every seller must make — and the six months of work that protect your price before a buyer is watching.
Written by
Martin Kotze
Attorney, Conveyancer & Notary Public
Contents
1. Where Deals Actually Go Wrong
None of the failures on this page is exotic. They are the ordinary failures that recur on deal after deal, in businesses run by capable people who have simply never done this before.
What they have in common is timing: nearly all of them are cheap to prevent months ahead of a buyer and expensive to repair once one is at the table. Several of them share a second feature, which is that they only reveal their cost long after closing day, when the money is spent and the leverage is gone.
Read the ten that follow as a checklist for the months before you go to market rather than as a list of things to worry about during the negotiation. If you work through only these ten before you talk to anyone, you will have removed most of what turns a good deal into a disappointing one.
2. The Ten Things That Go Wrong
Tax structuring left until the agreement is drafted
By the time a draft sale agreement is circulating, the structure is settled in everyone’s mind, the buyer’s board has approved a shape and a number, and your ability to change either has largely gone. Sellers who discover in week eight that the shares sit in the wrong entity, or that an asset structure costs them R7 million more, are not asking for an amendment. They are asking for a renegotiation — and buyers treat a renegotiation as a reason to look again at everything else too.
The fix: have the tax conversation before heads of terms, when the structure is still an open question.
Treating the data room as disclosure
Loading four thousand documents into a data room and adding a line saying everything in it is disclosed feels thorough and protects you against very little. The test is whether a reasonable buyer would have understood the problem and its size from what you gave them — and an unindexed folder of scanned PDFs fails that test comfortably. Twenty minutes spent writing an issue up properly removes a claim that could otherwise run into millions.
The fix: write specific disclosures against the specific warranties they qualify, in enough detail that the reader knows what the issue is and roughly what it is worth.
An earn-out agreed without controlling how it is measured
Sellers negotiate the earn-out number hard and the measurement barely at all, then spend two years watching the buyer allocate head-office costs, change the sales commission structure, move a product line and revise the accounting policies. None of that has to be done in bad faith to cost you the money; a buyer integrating your business will make those decisions for their own perfectly sensible reasons. On a R8 million earn-out they are worth more than anything you argued about at signature.
The fix: define the measure, fix the accounting policies that produce it, and secure a right to the information and a proper way to resolve a dispute about the number. See earn-outs, escrow & deferred payment.
A long stop date that was never realistic
The date the deal dies gets set at three months because that sounds businesslike, while the licence transfer sitting in the conditions list takes a regulator eight months on a good run. When the date arrives with conditions outstanding, the deal is technically dead and you are asking a buyer whose circumstances have changed to revive it, on their terms. Meanwhile you have run the business under restrictions for a quarter and told nobody why.
The fix: build the long stop date off the slowest item on the conditions list, add a margin, and write down how it can be extended while everyone is still friendly.
A change-of-control clause discovered during due diligence
Your biggest customer’s contract says the customer may terminate if the ownership of your company changes, and nobody read it until the buyer’s lawyers did in week five. Now it is the buyer’s discovery rather than your disclosure, it attaches to R11 million of your R30 million turnover, and it arrives with a price conversation attached. Found three months earlier, it is a manageable consent; found in diligence, it is leverage.
The fix: read your top ten contracts for change-of-control and transfer restrictions before you go to market, and decide how each one will be handled.
No employee schedule, and no written agreement on accrued liabilities
On a business sale the staff transfer whether or not anyone has prepared for it, and you and the buyer stay jointly liable for twelve months for what was owed before the transfer. Sellers who never do the written exercise on accrued leave, bonuses and severance find that liability unallocated, unpriced and entirely live when a claim arrives eleven months later. By then you have no records, no payroll system and no leverage.
The fix: build an accurate employee schedule early and agree the accrued liabilities in writing, with names and numbers, before the transfer date.
Signing warranties you have not personally read
The warranty schedule is long, technical and arrives late, and it is tempting to leave it to your advisors and your financial manager. But your advisors do not know whether your second-largest customer ever signed the standard terms, and your financial manager does not know what you promised a supplier verbally in 2019. You are the only person in the building who can answer most of these questions.
The fix: read every warranty yourself, line by line, and treat anything you cannot personally confirm as something to disclose rather than something to hope about.
A restraint that stops the thing you planned to do next
The restricted business is defined broadly, nobody carves anything out, and eighteen months later the consulting work you always intended to do, or the stake you hold in a supplier, or the venture your daughter is starting, turns out to be a breach. By then the buyer has paid, has no reason to accommodate you, and your choices are to abandon the plan or to litigate. The clause that causes this is almost never the number of years; it is the definition of what you may not do.
The fix: write down what you actually intend to do for the next three years, read the restraint against that list, and get the carve-outs into the agreement before you sign.
Completion accounts prepared by the buyer with no real right to review
If the price is trued up after closing, whoever prepares the accounts holds the pen, and by then you no longer have the business, the systems or the staff. A seller with no access to the records and no proper dispute mechanism is negotiating about their own money with nothing to negotiate with. A single change in how doubtful debts or slow stock are provided for can move the number by a million rand.
The fix: agree the accounting policies and a worked example before signature, and secure real access to information, a proper review period, and an independent expert to decide a deadlock. See locked box vs completion accounts.
Telling your staff too late, too early, or not at all
Tell them too early and you lose people during the months between heads of terms and closing, exactly when the buyer is assessing whether the business depends on individuals who are still there. Tell them on closing day and you spend twenty years of trust in an afternoon, and the buyer inherits a workforce that starts the new relationship suspicious. Neither failure shows up in the agreement, and both cost real money.
The fix: agree a communication plan with the buyer in advance — who is told, in what order, on what day, by whom, and what is said about job security. See the sale process & timeline.
In short
Look at that list again. Nine of the ten are failures of preparation and timing, not of negotiation. They are cheap to prevent months in advance and expensive to fix once a buyer is in the room.
3. Your Eight Decisions, on One Page
A business sale turns on eight real decisions. None of them has a universally right answer. Each is a trade between certainty and value, or between speed and protection, and the right answer depends on your business, your buyer and what you personally need from this sale.
Two things are worth saying before the table. The first is that these decisions are connected. A buyer who accepts a locked-box price is often the same buyer who wants a longer escrow. A seller who takes an earn-out is agreeing, in the same breath, to a longer restraint and a longer relationship. So decide them together rather than one at a time, and always in terms of the same number: what you actually receive, and when.
The second is that they are decided earlier than most sellers realise. By the time a sale agreement is being drafted, seven of these eight are effectively settled — they were settled in the heads of terms, in two pages, weeks before anyone opened a drafting file. That is the moment to have these arguments, and this table is the agenda for them.
The Eight Decisions — a Summary, Not a Substitute
| Decision | What it means | Points to one answer when | Points to the other when |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shares or the business | You sell the company itself, or you sell what is inside it | Shares: you are selling the whole business, the tax arithmetic favours you, and you want a clean break | Business: the buyer wants only part, there is history they will not touch, or the company holds assets you are keeping |
| Price fixed now or trued up later | Lock the number to a past balance sheet, or measure on closing day | Locked box: the gap to closing is short, your accounts are reliable, and you want certainty | Completion accounts: working capital swings a lot, the gap is long, or the accounts are not clean enough to lock |
| Conditions or a same-day deal | Sign now and close later, or do both at once | Same day: nothing genuinely stands in the way and the price is funded | Conditions: competition approval, funding, consents or licences must come first |
| How much is deferred, and how | What you actually receive on closing day | Less deferred: you need certainty, or your plans depend on the cash | More deferred: the buyer will not fund it all now and you are being paid for the wait |
| Escrow or not | Money held back to secure your promises | No escrow: you are clearly good for a claim and the buyer accepts that | Escrow: the buyer is unfamiliar with you, or a known risk needs security |
| Earn-out or not | Part of the price depends on future performance | No earn-out: you are leaving, or you will not control what is measured | Earn-out: you are staying, you believe the growth story, and you can bear losing it |
| Insurance or seller recourse | Who pays a warranty claim — an insurer or you | Insurance: you want a clean exit, or several sellers want no tail | Seller recourse: the deal is too small to carry the premium, or the cover excludes the risks that matter |
| Restraint scope | What you may not do afterwards, where, and for how long | Narrower: you have specific plans, or the business is regional | Wider: the buyer is paying for goodwill you personally hold, and the price reflects it |
The table is a summary, not a substitute for the detail. Use it to work out which conversations you need and in what order, then go to the page that deals with each.
Two of those decisions deserve a final word, because they carry the most money for the least attention.
Where your shares sit
The first is where your shares sit, which is decided years before the sale and can be worth several million rand at the end of it. It is the reason the tax conversation belongs at the start of the preparation, not at the end of the drafting.
The definition of the restricted business
The second is the definition of the restricted business in your restraint, which nobody argues about and which quietly determines what you are allowed to do with the next decade of your working life. Read it against your actual plans — see restraint of trade.
4. The One Thing Worth Doing Above Everything Else
If you take a single instruction from this guide, take this one. Prepare before you go to market.
Not because it is virtuous, but because of when it happens. Everything you do before a buyer appears, you do at your own pace, in your own time, with no clock running and nobody’s leverage over you. Everything you leave undone gets done later — under a long stop date, in front of a buyer’s advisors, with a price that can still move.
Concretely, that means the six months before you approach anyone. None of what follows is legal work. It is your work, done with your financial manager and your accountant, and most of it is the sort of housekeeping that a well-run business ought to have anyway. What makes it valuable is not virtue. It is that the same task costs a fraction of the price when there is no buyer watching.
5. The Six-Month Preparation Programme
Six pieces of work, done in the six months before you approach anyone:
Signed financial statements that agree with the management accounts
A buyer tests the annual financial statements against the management accounts early, and a gap between the two is the first thing that erodes trust in every other number you present. Get them signed, and get them agreeing.
A complete employee schedule
Start dates, remuneration and accrued balances, for every employee. On a business sale the staff transfer whether or not anyone has prepared for it, so the schedule and the written agreement on accrued liabilities need to exist before the transfer date, not after a claim arrives.
A contracts file with the change-of-control clauses already identified
Signed copies of your material contracts, with the change-of-control and transfer restrictions found and a decision made on how each will be handled — so that the clause in your biggest customer’s contract is your disclosure, not the buyer’s discovery.
Company records in order
Share register, directors, resolutions, minute book. These are the documents a buyer’s lawyers open first, and gaps in them read as gaps in everything else.
The tax conversation had and the structure settled
Before heads of terms, while the structure is still an open question — because where your shares sit is decided years before the sale and can be worth several million rand at the end of it.
Every known problem either fixed or written down with a number next to it
A buyer prices what surprises them. A problem you have fixed costs nothing; a problem you have quantified and written up costs its number; a problem the buyer finds costs its number plus a bigger escrow and a longer tail.
Watch out
None of this list is legal work, and none of it requires a buyer. That is precisely why it gets postponed — and precisely why postponing it is expensive. The same task costs a fraction of the price when there is no buyer watching, and everything left undone gets done later under a long stop date, in front of a buyer’s advisors, with a price that can still move.
6. What Preparation Buys You
That work does three things at once — and a fourth that sellers only notice afterwards.
It removes the discoveries that cost you price
A buyer prices what surprises them, and every surprise is also an argument for a bigger escrow and a longer tail. Work found and written up before the buyer arrives is a disclosure; work the buyer finds is a price conversation.
It shortens the process
A shorter process is cheaper and less risky, because deals die from delay far more often than from disagreement. See the sale process & timeline.
It changes how you are read across the table
A seller who produces what is asked for in two days is a seller running a business worth what they say it is worth, and that impression is worth more in a negotiation than any clause you will win.
It is what lets you walk away
A seller who is ready has options, can test the market properly, and can say no to a term that does not work. A seller who is not ready is committed to whoever is in front of them, because starting again means starting the preparation too.
You built this business over fifteen or twenty years. You will sell it once. The months you spend getting it ready are the best-paid months of the whole exercise.
In short
The value of preparation is not that it makes the deal pleasant. It is that it is the only part of the process you control completely, and it is the only work in the whole transaction that you do without anyone’s leverage over you.
7. Before You Go to Market
The sellers who do best are rarely the ones with the best business. They are the ones who were ready. They knew what they were selling and how the price would be settled before they had a buyer. Their contracts, employee records and tax affairs were in order. They had decided what they would concede and what they would not. And they had run the numbers on what they would actually receive, on the day, after everything deferred and everything held back.
None of that requires a buyer. All of it can be done now.
Get Ready Before a Buyer Is Watching
MJ Kotze Inc runs sale-readiness reviews for business owners planning an exit: the tax conversation before heads of terms, the contracts file with change-of-control clauses identified, the employee schedule and accrued liabilities, the company records, and a written plan for every known problem — so that when a buyer arrives, the work is already done and the leverage is yours.
For the businesses we act for
The Keystone Workspace
The attorney-designed platform the businesses we act for use to run their contracts, e-signatures and company secretarial work in one place.
Why you can trust this: Martin Kotze has been an admitted Attorney of the High Court of South Africa, registered Conveyancer, and Notary Public since 2014, practising from Pretoria. The firm is regulated by the Legal Practice Council under firm registration 17444.
This guide is general information, not legal advice for your specific matter.