Twelve-dimension comparison
| Dimension | In-House Counsel | Outsourced Specialist |
|---|---|---|
| Annual fully-loaded cost | R1.2m – R2.5m (mid-level GC, our illustrative estimate) | From R300k (R25,000/month minimum retainer), plus any fixed-fee project work |
| Hours of expert availability | Full-time within working hours | Ten retainer hours a month + ad-hoc bespoke — not equivalent to a full-time hire |
| Specialist depth (POPIA, AI, fintech) | Depends on the hire; one person rarely covers every specialism | Specialist by design |
| Embedded business knowledge | Deep, accumulated | Reasonable, builds over time |
| Surge capacity (M&A, funding, dispute) | Limited — single person | Additional work engaged on demand, subject to availability |
| Conflict-of-interest management | Aligned with the employer, though internal reporting lines can create their own tensions | Conflict checks on each matter |
| Best for early-stage tech companies | Premature — cost-prohibitive | Right-sized — pay for what you need |
| Best for Series B+ companies | Increasingly justified | Often a complement, not a replacement |
| External vendor contract review | Limited by single bandwidth | Fixed-fee review per document, outside the retainer hours |
| Day-to-day commercial advice | Available immediately | Available within retainer hours |
| Cost predictability | High (fixed salary) | High (fixed retainer + fixed-fee bespoke) |
| Right answer for most SA tech companies under ARR R100m | Premature | Right-sized |
When in-house starts to justify itself
A few or all of these indicators suggest the in-house tipping point has been reached:
- Annual recurring revenue (ARR) approaching R100m
- Three or more substantive commercial transactions per month requiring legal review
- Active M&A pipeline or strategic-investor diligence repeating
- Multi-jurisdiction operations requiring sustained cross-border expertise
- Active regulatory engagement (Information Regulator, FSCA, SARB) repeating
- Internal team headcount approaching 200+ employees with HR/employment-law volume
For most SA tech businesses, outsourced is right-sized
Monthly retainers from R25,000/month (ten hours at R2,500, with priority access and the Keystone Workspace included); project-based bespoke from R12,150; fixed-fee contract review from R1,897. You pay for what you need.